Skip to content

docs(workstation): add My Station and Agent Station audit reports - #1854

Merged
Harry19081 merged 1 commit into
developfrom
docs/station-audit-2026-09-16
Sep 16, 2026
Merged

Harry19081 merged 1 commit into
developfrom
docs/station-audit-2026-09-16

Conversation

@Chloe-JY

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator

Problem

The station surfaces had no current audit in the tree. The previous pass (PR #1842) was never merged: it lives only on origin/docs/my-station-audit, five commits behind develop and mixed with unrelated Spotlight and branch-switch work, so it is not a clean cherry-pick and nothing is visible to anyone working in the repo today.

Solution

Two reports from a read-only pass over My Station and Agent Station — 886 source files, roughly 136,000 lines, across code quality, performance and user experience.

  • docs/architecture-audit-2026-09-16/MyStationAgentStation.md — 3 findings that cause user-visible data loss or breakage, 13 correctness and 18 performance defects, 18 dead-code and contract findings, plus sweeps, test gaps, a verified-healthy list, and a table of the 2026-09-14 items re-checked as still open.
  • docs/frontend-ui-audit-2026-09-16/MyStationAgentStationUX.md — 52 rows in the frontend-ui-audit verdict format: 41 fix, 3 abstract, 7 keep with reason, 1 watch.

Both follow the report formats in .orgii/skills/*/SKILL.md. Findings are cited by file:line and each carries a confidence marker separating what was traced end to end from what is plausible and names the check that would confirm it.

The architecture report also records a correction to its own proposed fix for the agent-edit case. The suggested "bridge file:changed" would have been inert — the Rust emitter has no callers — and actively harmful, because the subscription it would have fed clobbers unsaved edits. Keeping that correction in the report matters more than keeping the report tidy.

Five findings have since been fixed; those PRs are listed in the report's "Fixed in this pass" section, and the three rows in the UX report are marked applied.

Potential risks

Documentation only. No source, config or test file changes, so no runtime, build or CI behaviour is affected and there is nothing to roll back beyond deleting the two files.

The reports are a point-in-time snapshot against develop 224b6a4d5b. Line references drift as the tree moves, and the companion docs/*-2026-09-14/ reports they compose with are still unmerged, so the "carried over" table is the only place those items are visible on develop.

Verification

  • prettier --check on both files — clean. (lint-staged runs prettier --write on *.md, which pads every table; these files are padded to match the existing audit docs.)
  • Every P0 and every finding marked verified was independently re-checked against source by the audit lead before the report was written; the re-check list is in the report's Verification section.
  • The three read-only scripts quoted in the report were actually run: check-test-placement.mjs, i18n-keys/check.mjs --json, and a scoped knip run whose 212 entries were re-verified by a full-src reference scan before any were called dead.

No code changed, so no typecheck, lint or test run applies. The commit was built with git plumbing from a shared dirty checkout, so no pre-commit hook ran and there is no "Pre-commit hook ran." trailer.

Read-only audit of both station surfaces across code quality, performance and
user experience: 886 source files, three findings that cause user-visible data
loss or breakage, 31 further defects, and 52 UX verdicts.

The architecture report also records a correction to its own proposed fix for
the agent-edit case, and the follow-ups the fixes could not close.
@Harry19081
Harry19081 merged commit ab645b2 into develop Sep 16, 2026
13 checks passed
@Harry19081

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Member

I plan to do a follow-up audit.

@Harry19081 Harry19081 added documentation Documentation-only work workstation Workstation, editor, source control, LSP, or status bar labels Sep 16, 2026
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

documentation Documentation-only work workstation Workstation, editor, source control, LSP, or status bar

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants