Describe the bug
The "P5 - BIS (WIP)" presets across multiple classes and specs (melee, ranged, casters, healers) currently use standard Heroic Warforged weapons (ilvl 580 fully upgraded). However, the absolute Best-in-Slot weapons for Phase 5 (Patch 5.4 Siege of Orgrimmar) are the Garrosh Hellscream Heirlooms on Heroic difficulty (often tagged as Mythic in modern databases), which reach ilvl 582 when fully upgraded.
These Heirloom weapons provide the highest weapon damage, spell power, and raw stats in the tier, but they are currently missing from the BiS preset configurations across the board.
To Reproduce
Steps to reproduce the behavior:
- Go to almost any class simulator (e.g., Monk -> Windwalker, Warrior -> Arms/Fury, Hunter, etc.).
- Click on the 'Gear' tab.
- Select the 'P5 - BIS (WIP)' preset in the Gear Sets menu.
- Check the equipped weapons.
- See that it equips ilvl 580 Heroic Warforged weapons (e.g., Korven's Crimson Crescent for WW Monk) instead of the mathematically superior ilvl 582 Garrosh Heirloom weapons (e.g., Hellscream's Cleaver).
Expected behavior
The Phase 5 BiS presets should utilize the fully upgraded Garrosh Heirloom weapons (ilvl 582) where applicable, as their higher item level makes them the undisputed BiS for the final tier. If these heirlooms are currently missing from the simulator's item database (possibly due to being flagged as scaling items), they need to be implemented and added to the default BiS lists.
Sim Links and Screenshots
I am attaching a screenshot of the WW Monk P5 BiS preset as an example, but this issue applies globally to all classes missing their respective Garrosh weapons.
Desktop (please complete the following information):
- OS: Windows 10
- Browser: Firefox
- Version: 151.0.3 (64-bit)
Smartphone (please complete the following information):
Additional context
Examples of the missing ilvl 582 weapons include:
- Hellscream's Cleaver (1H Agility Axe)
- Hellscream's Decapitator (2H Strength Axe)
- Hellscream's Warbow (Agility Bow)
- Hellscream's Tome of Destruction (Caster Off-hand)
- Hellscream's Pig Sticker (Agility Polearm)
- And all other difficulty variants.
Since these items are technically Heirloom quality (light blue text), they might have been filtered out or missed by the gear selection logic when the P5 presets were generated.
Describe the bug
The "P5 - BIS (WIP)" presets across multiple classes and specs (melee, ranged, casters, healers) currently use standard Heroic Warforged weapons (ilvl 580 fully upgraded). However, the absolute Best-in-Slot weapons for Phase 5 (Patch 5.4 Siege of Orgrimmar) are the Garrosh Hellscream Heirlooms on Heroic difficulty (often tagged as Mythic in modern databases), which reach ilvl 582 when fully upgraded.
These Heirloom weapons provide the highest weapon damage, spell power, and raw stats in the tier, but they are currently missing from the BiS preset configurations across the board.
To Reproduce
Steps to reproduce the behavior:
Expected behavior
The Phase 5 BiS presets should utilize the fully upgraded Garrosh Heirloom weapons (ilvl 582) where applicable, as their higher item level makes them the undisputed BiS for the final tier. If these heirlooms are currently missing from the simulator's item database (possibly due to being flagged as scaling items), they need to be implemented and added to the default BiS lists.
Sim Links and Screenshots
I am attaching a screenshot of the WW Monk P5 BiS preset as an example, but this issue applies globally to all classes missing their respective Garrosh weapons.
Desktop (please complete the following information):
Smartphone (please complete the following information):
Additional context
Examples of the missing ilvl 582 weapons include:
Since these items are technically Heirloom quality (light blue text), they might have been filtered out or missed by the gear selection logic when the P5 presets were generated.