Skip to content

TODO-API-ALTERNATIVES.md

Latest commit

 

History

History
105 lines (84 loc) · 3.27 KB

TODO-API-ALTERNATIVES.md

File metadata and controls

105 lines (84 loc) · 3.27 KB
Raw

TODO: Alternative AI Music Generation APIs

Problem

The unofficial Suno API (sunoapi.org) has been discontinued, so we need alternative solutions for AI music generation.

Alternative Solutions

1. Udio API (Most Similar to Suno)

  • URL: https://udio.com
  • Status: Has unofficial API wrappers available
  • Features: Text-to-music generation, style control, high quality output
  • Implementation: Update SunoClient to UdioClient

2. MusicGen by Meta (Open Source)

3. Stable Audio by Stability AI

  • URL: https://stableaudio.com
  • Status: Has API access
  • Features: High-quality audio generation, commercial use
  • Implementation: Create StableAudioClient

4. Mubert API (Commercial)

  • URL: https://mubert.com/api
  • Status: Official API available
  • Features: Royalty-free music generation, style control
  • Implementation: Create MubertClient

5. Local Generation with MusicGen

  • Implementation: Run MusicGen locally via Python subprocess
  • Pros: No API costs, full control
  • Cons: Requires local setup, slower generation

Recommended Implementation Plan

Phase 1: Multi-Provider Architecture

  1. Create abstract MusicGenerationClient base class
  2. Implement provider-specific clients (Udio, MusicGen, etc.)
  3. Add provider selection via environment variable
  4. Update CLI to support multiple providers

Phase 2: Provider-Specific Features

  1. Udio: Direct Suno-like replacement
  2. MusicGen: Local generation option
  3. Mubert: Commercial-grade generation
  4. Stable Audio: High-quality output

Phase 3: Fallback System

  1. Implement provider fallback chain
  2. Auto-retry with different providers on failure
  3. Provider health checking

Implementation Strategy

// Abstract base class
class MusicGenerationClient {
  async generateSong(params) { throw new Error('Not implemented'); }
  async getGenerationStatus(id) { throw new Error('Not implemented'); }
  async downloadSong(url) { throw new Error('Not implemented'); }
}

// Provider implementations
class UdioClient extends MusicGenerationClient { ... }
class MusicGenClient extends MusicGenerationClient { ... }
class MubertClient extends MusicGenerationClient { ... }

// Factory pattern
class MusicClientFactory {
  static create(provider) {
    switch(provider) {
      case 'udio': return new UdioClient();
      case 'musicgen': return new MusicGenClient();
      case 'mubert': return new MubertClient();
      default: throw new Error(`Unknown provider: ${provider}`);
    }
  }
}

Environment Configuration

# Primary provider
MUSIC_PROVIDER=udio

# Provider-specific configs
UDIO_API_TOKEN=your_token
MUSICGEN_API_TOKEN=your_hf_token
MUBERT_API_TOKEN=your_token
STABLE_AUDIO_API_TOKEN=your_token

# Fallback chain
MUSIC_FALLBACK_PROVIDERS=udio,musicgen,mubert

Migration Path

  1. Immediate: Update documentation to mention API discontinuation
  2. Short-term: Implement Udio client as direct replacement
  3. Medium-term: Add MusicGen and Mubert support
  4. Long-term: Full multi-provider architecture with fallbacks