Skip to content

Add inventory-sensitivity gate before BrC chemistry/optics claims #9

Description

@maxcharvey

Problem

The wiki repeatedly flags fire inventory uncertainty as large enough to mimic or dominate BrC chemistry/optics changes. The current implementation tracker has code-level BrC/RRTMG issues, but no explicit gate requiring GFED vs inventory/scaling sensitivity before attributing model-observation changes to BrC physics.

Wiki basis

  • wiki/projects/brc-modeling/current-brc-implementation-checklist.md: step 4, run inventory interaction check.
  • registries/run_matrix.yml: BRC_VISCBLEACH_SCALE3X_WUS_OFFAOD, allowed inventories GFED, FINN, QFED, GFAS, SCALE3X_WUS.
  • wiki/projects/validation/geos-chem-brc-validation-plan.md: compare fire inventory sensitivity before chemistry attribution.

Needed

  • Define minimum inventory/scaling sensitivity after the first combined BrC branch passes short tests.
  • Record which HEMCO configs and inventory versions are used.
  • Keep western-US scaling separate from global default claims.

Acceptance

  • BrC optics/lifetime improvements are not called production-ready until at least one inventory/scaling sensitivity has been compared.
  • Run names follow BRC_<physics>_<inventory>_<operator>_<yyyymmdd>.

Wiki audit: [[brc-implementation-audit-2026-06-30#Validation]]

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    brcBrown carbon implementationextensionFuture extensionvalidationValidation and run checks

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions